{"study":"M4-P2-E007-INTERVENTION-CONTRAST-TRANSPORT/0.1.0","protocol":"research/M4P2_FROZEN_PROTOCOL.md","protocolFreezeCommit":"7596321ca5e2735d5002f770055b268764ef3705","sourceGitCommit":"6d9de56502973499fa264005fd24bd313cc344cc","independentlyAudited":true,"independentNewEcologyOrigins":12,"pairedWorlds":72,"earlyCutoffTick":230,"futureStartTick":231,"futureEndTick":390,"originalM4P1FitSha256":"156e2bf80e388bff766ce4d59df290a31f6329dab7572531f7669c1187f4a0ac","fitUnchangedSinceM4P1":true,"oldM4P1HoldoutNotUsedForTraining":true,"sourceArchives":[{"group":"A","file":"M4P2-A-4seed.json","manifest":"M4P2-A-audit.json","rawSha256":"e5ba31ab8041dae0860252381474569f611e1b309ecd4338cd5420f59168b913"},{"group":"B","file":"M4P2-B-4seed.json","manifest":"M4P2-B-audit.json","rawSha256":"324aa7bb6b07f6010bcb60f45d453ffd4440647cd5a2f5ab1c8bfa9b7500a768"},{"group":"C","file":"M4P2-C-4seed.json","manifest":"M4P2-C-audit.json","rawSha256":"8951ac4be653ca6ea4c8133f8a7234786cdca5647e7a709afb2aa2f9fdd193da"}],"prespecifiedPrimary":{"treated":"inherited","control":"no_social","primary":true,"meanActualEffect":0.08278768209100784,"meanPredictedEffect":0.06424053744184229,"meanAbsoluteErrorPhi":0.3651941686411993,"meanAbsoluteErrorZero":0.46618716334334637,"meanAbsoluteErrorEarly":1.4787651407020899,"advantageOverNull":{"mean":0.10099299470214707,"bootstrap95":[-0.010646254801205993,0.22973178655735774],"positive":7,"negative":5,"ties":0,"perIndependentOrigin":[{"seed":15100107,"improvement":0.24481213215000608},{"seed":15108026,"improvement":-0.039214634571585805},{"seed":15115945,"improvement":0.006465945472770684},{"seed":15123864,"improvement":-0.0815990497167931},{"seed":15200107,"improvement":0.27374733051800426},{"seed":15208026,"improvement":0.031597769708266554},{"seed":15215945,"improvement":-0.07755287380674503},{"seed":15223864,"improvement":-0.12207369243757071},{"seed":15300107,"improvement":0.5034601546281952},{"seed":15308026,"improvement":0.12188432084497691},{"seed":15315945,"improvement":-0.10293317376576816},{"seed":15323864,"improvement":0.45332170740200795}]},"advantageOverEarly":{"mean":1.1135709720608904,"bootstrap95":[0.5329171158098123,1.7300549670334646],"positive":11,"negative":1,"ties":0,"perIndependentOrigin":[{"seed":15100107,"improvement":1.9614877487393407},{"seed":15108026,"improvement":0.18514374955697477},{"seed":15115945,"improvement":0.8484664120879994},{"seed":15123864,"improvement":0.2740695556387589},{"seed":15200107,"improvement":0.5236759223489091},{"seed":15208026,"improvement":1.3113026706036095},{"seed":15215945,"improvement":1.1622719097594771},{"seed":15223864,"improvement":2.4055724371042935},{"seed":15300107,"improvement":3.2175449950129966},{"seed":15308026,"improvement":0.9640674032550383},{"seed":15315945,"improvement":-0.9490157613120918},{"seed":15323864,"improvement":1.4582646219353776}]},"directionCorrect":9,"exactZeroActualContrasts":0,"signGatePassed":true,"successGate":false,"interpretation":"NOT CONFIRMED: one or more preregistered intervention-contrast gates failed","perSeed":[{"seed":15100107,"actual":-0.4366254827193554,"predicted":-0.24481213215000608,"baselineEarly":1.7166756165893347,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.19181335056934934,"absoluteErrorZero":0.4366254827193554,"absoluteErrorEarly":2.15330109930869,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15108026,"actual":-0.9314705028521484,"predicted":0.039214634571585805,"baselineEarly":0.22435838412856057,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.9706851374237342,"absoluteErrorZero":0.9314705028521484,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.155828886980709,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15115945,"actual":-0.1535122626934804,"predicted":-0.006465945472770684,"baselineEarly":0.8420004666152288,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.1470463172207097,"absoluteErrorZero":0.1535122626934804,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.9955127293087092,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15123864,"actual":0.02611062637216932,"predicted":0.13382030246113175,"baselineEarly":-0.355668605355552,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.10770967608896242,"absoluteErrorZero":0.02611062637216932,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.3817792317277213,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15200107,"actual":0.28834399335246985,"predicted":0.30294065618693544,"baselineEarly":-0.24992859183090488,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.01459666283446559,"absoluteErrorZero":0.28834399335246985,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.5382725851833747,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15208026,"actual":-0.5016223163889535,"predicted":-0.031597769708266554,"baselineEarly":1.279704900895343,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.47002454668068694,"absoluteErrorZero":0.5016223163889535,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.7813272172842964,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15215945,"actual":0.1734836246144802,"predicted":-0.07755287380674503,"baselineEarly":1.5867920327951825,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.2510364984212252,"absoluteErrorZero":0.1734836246144802,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.4133084081807024,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15223864,"actual":-0.11011000321238384,"predicted":-0.3422936988623384,"baselineEarly":2.527646129541864,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.23218369564995456,"absoluteErrorZero":0.11011000321238384,"absoluteErrorEarly":2.637756132754248,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15300107,"actual":0.6362946089597568,"predicted":0.7691290632913184,"baselineEarly":-2.7140848403848015,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.1328344543315616,"absoluteErrorZero":0.6362946089597568,"absoluteErrorEarly":3.3503794493445582,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15308026,"actual":-0.16705631964770973,"predicted":-0.12188432084497691,"baselineEarly":0.8421830824100613,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.045171998802732816,"absoluteErrorZero":0.16705631964770973,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.009239402057771,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15315945,"actual":0.9048664935179076,"predicted":-0.10293317376576816,"baselineEarly":0.9636503994894916,"absoluteErrorPhi":1.0077996672836758,"absoluteErrorZero":0.9048664935179076,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.058783905971584005,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15323864,"actual":1.2647497257893416,"predicted":0.45332170740200795,"baselineEarly":-1.0049429145333697,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.8114280183873337,"absoluteErrorZero":1.2647497257893416,"absoluteErrorEarly":2.2696926403227113,"signCorrect":true}]},"secondaryScrambled":{"treated":"inherited","control":"scrambled","primary":false,"meanActualEffect":-0.16752393249109318,"meanPredictedEffect":0.09756966680168455,"meanAbsoluteErrorPhi":0.8204396905596362,"meanAbsoluteErrorZero":0.8898823003052923,"meanAbsoluteErrorEarly":1.34170839999875,"advantageOverNull":{"mean":0.06944260974565604,"bootstrap95":[-0.05082971988247224,0.21055085848883218],"positive":6,"negative":6,"ties":0,"perIndependentOrigin":[{"seed":15100107,"improvement":-0.05736813758209003},{"seed":15108026,"improvement":0.017313176062993207},{"seed":15115945,"improvement":0.343351338605709},{"seed":15123864,"improvement":-0.05284387027117177},{"seed":15200107,"improvement":0.08326134558515719},{"seed":15208026,"improvement":-0.13610657250915636},{"seed":15215945,"improvement":0.18834680660373948},{"seed":15223864,"improvement":-0.020136883379208825},{"seed":15300107,"improvement":0.6743239492186532},{"seed":15308026,"improvement":-0.2761799155480311},{"seed":15315945,"improvement":0.10890219393721523},{"seed":15323864,"improvement":-0.039552113775936704}]},"advantageOverEarly":{"mean":0.5212687094391136,"bootstrap95":[0.05446125714523875,1.1409586317392175],"positive":8,"negative":4,"ties":0,"perIndependentOrigin":[{"seed":15100107,"improvement":-0.2472753525520428},{"seed":15108026,"improvement":0.21920228126163543},{"seed":15115945,"improvement":1.5866710366800785},{"seed":15123864,"improvement":-0.2958579187714854},{"seed":15200107,"improvement":-0.01031153432073495},{"seed":15208026,"improvement":0.08279353195714734},{"seed":15215945,"improvement":0.33733317766521864},{"seed":15223864,"improvement":-0.1650168202011919},{"seed":15300107,"improvement":3.2960440551703893},{"seed":15308026,"improvement":0.06583214438319018},{"seed":15315945,"improvement":0.8085001680180817},{"seed":15323864,"improvement":0.5773097439790771}]},"directionCorrect":6,"exactZeroActualContrasts":0,"signGatePassed":false,"successGate":false,"interpretation":"NOT CONFIRMED: one or more preregistered intervention-contrast gates failed","perSeed":[{"seed":15100107,"actual":-0.7840357064303838,"predicted":0.05736813758209003,"baselineEarly":-0.18990721496995278,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.8414038440124738,"absoluteErrorZero":0.7840357064303838,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.594128491460431,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15108026,"actual":-2.102632210000648,"predicted":-0.017313176062993207,"baselineEarly":0.20188910519864223,"absoluteErrorPhi":2.0853190339376546,"absoluteErrorZero":2.102632210000648,"absoluteErrorEarly":2.30452131519929,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15115945,"actual":0.3524583568037336,"predicted":0.3615653750017582,"baselineEarly":-1.2433196980743695,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.009107018198024619,"absoluteErrorZero":0.3524583568037336,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.595778054878103,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15123864,"actual":-0.2529752328370716,"predicted":0.05284387027117177,"baselineEarly":-0.26293641717382954,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.30581910310824334,"absoluteErrorZero":0.2529752328370716,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.009961184336757967,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15200107,"actual":0.2320150526320024,"predicted":0.08326134558515719,"baselineEarly":0.09357287990589214,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.1487537070468452,"absoluteErrorZero":0.2320150526320024,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.13844217272611026,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15208026,"actual":-2.0933362872792607,"predicted":0.13610657250915636,"baselineEarly":0.2189001044663037,"absoluteErrorPhi":2.229442859788417,"absoluteErrorZero":2.0933362872792607,"absoluteErrorEarly":2.3122363917455644,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15215945,"actual":1.1154296096639147,"predicted":0.18834680660373948,"baselineEarly":-0.14898637106147916,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.9270828030601752,"absoluteErrorZero":1.1154296096639147,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.2644159807253939,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15223864,"actual":0.3415400577696328,"predicted":-0.020136883379208825,"baselineEarly":0.5382001787172825,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.36167694114884164,"absoluteErrorZero":0.3415400577696328,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.19666012094764973,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15300107,"actual":1.8217974410359172,"predicted":0.6743239492186532,"baselineEarly":-2.621720105951736,"absoluteErrorPhi":1.147473491817264,"absoluteErrorZero":1.8217974410359172,"absoluteErrorEarly":4.443517546987653,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15308026,"actual":0.47090968897999375,"predicted":-0.2761799155480311,"baselineEarly":1.2838314378912088,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.7470896045280249,"absoluteErrorZero":0.47090968897999375,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.812921748911215,"signCorrect":false},{"seed":15315945,"actual":-0.9315941458083827,"predicted":-0.10890219393721523,"baselineEarly":0.6995979740808664,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.8226919518711675,"absoluteErrorZero":0.9315941458083827,"absoluteErrorEarly":1.6311921198892492,"signCorrect":true},{"seed":15323864,"actual":-0.17986381442256594,"predicted":0.039552113775936704,"baselineEarly":0.6168618577550138,"absoluteErrorPhi":0.21941592819850264,"absoluteErrorZero":0.17986381442256594,"absoluteErrorEarly":0.7967256721775797,"signCorrect":false}]},"scope":"One engineered E007 contrast only; successful prediction is not general interventional equivalence or consciousness.","limitations":["Six arms of each origin are dependent and evaluated as ONE cluster.","Early social intervention is assigned at tick151, NOT new at forecast cutoff230.","Sequential per-arm rollout: each forecast before its own future; earlier arms later outcomes are not supplied to any forecasting function.","M4-P1's predictive fit is reused unchanged; no M4-P2 or M4-P1 holdout tuning.","Even a positive result tests only one engineered E007 social-off contrast, not universal cross-level causal abstraction."]}